A market drop rarely stays quiet. Headlines move fast, portfolio balances shift in real time, and it can feel like the only responsible thing to do is act. Sell before it gets worse. Wait on the sidelines until things calm down. Move into something that feels safer.

That instinct is understandable. It’s also, more often than not, the wrong move. Decades of market data tell a more reassuring story than the one playing out in the moment, and understanding that story is often the difference between a plan that works and one that gets abandoned right when it matters most.

What decades of market history show

Markets have never moved in a straight line, and they never will. But zoom out far enough, and the picture becomes far calmer than any single week or month would suggest. Since 1985, a dollar invested in world equities has grown to roughly $62 in Canadian dollar terms, compared to about $8 for short-term government bonds and $5 for treasury bills, comfortably outpacing inflation along the way. That growth happened despite living through Black Monday, the dot-com crash, the global financial crisis, and the COVID-19 pandemic — not in spite of avoiding them.

Zooming in on any single year tells a different story. Since 1926, the US stock market has returned close to 10% annually on average, yet only a handful of years actually landed close to that average. Annual returns have ranged from gains above 50% to losses above 40%, and the typical year looks nothing like the long-term number. That gap between the smooth long-term average and the choppy year-to-year reality is exactly what makes staying invested feel harder than it should.

It also helps to know what tends to happen after a downturn, not just during one. Following market declines of 10%, 20%, and 30%, returns over the following one, three, and five years have, on average, been positive, with five-year cumulative returns often exceeding 50%. Bear markets, meaning declines of 20% or more, have historically lasted around 10 months on average, while the bull markets that followed lasted closer to four and a half years. The recoveries have consistently outlasted and outpaced the declines that preceded them.

Even within a single calendar year, a scary stretch doesn’t necessarily mean a losing one. Looking at US markets over the past two decades, intrayear declines have ranged as high as nearly 50%, yet the market still finished the year in positive territory in the large majority of those years. A rough few months and a rough year are not the same thing, even though they can feel identical while you’re living through them.

There’s also a timing lesson buried in how markets actually behave around bad news. During the 2008 recession, stock prices had already fallen more than 40% by the time the recession was officially confirmed, and markets had already largely recovered by the time the recession’s end was announced more than a year later. Markets tend to move on expectations well before headlines catch up, which means reacting to the news is often reacting to something the market priced in long ago.

Why the instinct to react runs so deep

None of this means downturns don’t sting. They do, and for a very specific reason: losses tend to feel considerably more painful than equivalent gains feel good. A drop in a portfolio’s value registers more sharply than a rise of the same size, which is part of why market declines can feel more dramatic and more threatening than the historical data would suggest they should.

That imbalance gets amplified by how often people check in. The more frequently a portfolio is monitored, the more often a decline is likely to be sitting there on the screen, and each glance carries a disproportionate emotional weight. Over time, that steady drip of discomfort can push toward decisions made in reaction to a bad week rather than in service of a long-term plan — decisions that are often the opposite of what the data would recommend.

Recognizing this pattern doesn’t make the discomfort disappear, but it does explain a lot about why staying the course is simple in theory and difficult in practice. It also helps explain why a downturn that, historically, is far more likely to be followed by a recovery than not can still feel, in the moment, like the start of something worse.

Why a disciplined plan matters more than a reaction

This is where a plan earns its keep. A portfolio built around broad diversification, rather than concentrated bets on any single company, sector, or country, is designed to capture returns wherever they show up rather than depending on any one part of the market getting it right. That structure doesn’t prevent downturns, but it means no single event has to define the outcome.

Staying invested through the rough stretches matters just as much as how the portfolio is built in the first place. Trying to sidestep the worst days by moving to cash usually means missing the best days too, since the two tend to cluster close together, often within the same volatile weeks. A plan that stays invested through both is positioned to capture the recovery that history suggests is likely to follow.

What discipline looks like in practice depends on where someone sits in their financial life. Someone still years from retirement can generally afford to look through short-term volatility with the least urgency. Someone drawing income from their portfolio in retirement has less room to simply wait it out and needs a withdrawal strategy built with volatility in mind from the start. And for incorporated business owners, a downturn in a corporate investment account carries its own considerations, layered on top of the personal ones, that make a one-size-fits-all reaction even less appropriate.

What ties all of it together is the same idea: the plan, not the headline of the day, should be driving the decision. Markets have rewarded patience far more consistently than they’ve rewarded reaction, and a plan built with volatility already in mind is what makes that patience possible to sustain. When the next downturn arrives, and it will, the question worth asking isn’t whether to react. It’s whether the plan already accounted for this.

Gabriel Horacio Ron Lleras is an Associate Financial Advisor with CI Assante Wealth Management Ltd. The opinions expressed are those of the author and not necessarily those of CI Assante Wealth Management Ltd. Please visit www.tmfg.ca to discuss your circumstances prior to acting on the information above. CI Assante Wealth Management Ltd. is a Member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund and the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization.