For many successful business owners and incorporated professionals, the corporation is more than just a vehicle for earning income; it can also become a powerful tool for building and preserving long-term wealth.
Once a business begins generating profits beyond what is needed to cover operating expenses and personal spending, owners are often faced with an important question: should excess funds remain within the corporation, or should they be withdrawn personally and invested outside the company?
The answer depends on a variety of factors, including tax rates, retirement objectives, estate planning considerations, and cash flow needs. While every situation is unique, understanding the basics of corporate investing can help business owners make more informed decisions and identify opportunities that may otherwise be overlooked.
Why invest through a corporation?
One of the primary advantages of incorporation in Canada is the ability to defer personal taxation.
Many small business owners benefit from the Small Business Deduction,1 which allows active business income to be taxed at substantially lower rates than top personal marginal tax rates. The federal net rate on the first $500,000 of active business income is 9%, compared to the general federal corporate tax rate, which is significantly higher.
Rather than withdrawing all profits immediately and paying personal tax, business owners can leave surplus cash inside the corporation and invest it. Although taxes will eventually be paid when funds are withdrawn personally, the corporation will have more capital available to invest in the meantime, creating an opportunity to compound assets and defer taxes.
An important item to note is that access to the reduced small business rate is restricted for corporations that earn passive investment income exceeding $50,000 in the previous taxation year, and the SBD is eliminated entirely at $150,000 of passive investment income. Business owners with growing investment portfolios inside their corporations should monitor this threshold carefully.
Operating companies and holding companies
When discussing corporate investing, it is common to hear references to operating companies and holding companies.
An operating company (OpCo) is the business entity that actively conducts operations — where revenue is earned, employees are paid, and business activities take place.
A holding company (HoldCo), by contrast, generally exists to own assets rather than conduct active business operations. These assets may include investment portfolios, real estate, or shares of an operating company.
Many business owners establish a holding company to separate investment assets from business operations. This structure can provide additional flexibility and, in some circumstances, help protect accumulated wealth from risks associated with the operating business.
When structured appropriately, surplus funds can often be transferred from an operating company to a holding company on a tax-deferred basis through intercorporate dividends. The holding company can then invest those funds independently of the operating business.
It is important to note that investment income earned by an associated holding company will be included in the passive income calculation for the operating company and may reduce income qualifying for the small business deduction.
The suitability of an OpCo/HoldCo structure depends on legal, tax, and business considerations and should always be reviewed with qualified professional advisors.
Understanding corporate investment income
Once funds are invested within a corporation, the tax treatment differs significantly from investing personally.
Unlike active business income, passive income earned in a corporation is taxed at approximately 50% across Canada.
At first glance, this may seem disadvantageous. However, Canada’s corporate tax system contains mechanisms designed to help achieve a degree of tax integration when profits are ultimately distributed to shareholders.
Two of the most important concepts are refundable taxes and the Capital Dividend Account.
What are refundable taxes?
A unique feature of Canada’s corporate tax system is the Refundable Dividend Tax on Hand (RDTOH)2 account.
When a corporation earns passive investment income, a portion of the tax paid is added to this account. The corporation may recover some of these taxes when it pays taxable dividends to shareholders.
The rationale is straightforward: the government collects additional tax upfront on passive income earned inside corporations, but a portion can be refunded when funds are eventually distributed personally. As a result, corporate investing should not be evaluated solely on the initial tax bill, because the eventual withdrawal strategy plays a significant role in determining the overall after-tax outcome.
For this reason, corporate investment planning and personal retirement planning are closely connected.
The capital dividend account
The Capital Dividend Account (CDA)3 is one of the most valuable, and least understood, features of corporate tax planning.
When a corporation realizes a capital gain, only half of that gain is taxable. The non-taxable half is added to the corporation’s CDA balance. The CDA tracks the non-taxed portion of capital gains realized within corporations, and when there is a balance in the account, it can be paid out to Canadian-resident shareholders tax-free.
For example, if a corporation realizes a $100,000 capital gain, $50,000 will be taxable. The remaining $50,000 may be added to the CDA and distributed to shareholders without additional personal tax.
Life insurance proceeds received by a corporation can also create CDA credits in certain circumstances, which is one reason corporate-owned life insurance is frequently discussed in advanced estate and succession planning strategies.
Accessing corporate funds for personal use
Eventually, most business owners will want to access some or all of their corporate wealth. There are several common methods of doing so.
1. Salary
Salary is deductible to the corporation and creates earned income for the shareholder. It generates RRSP contribution room and contributes to CPP benefits. However, salary is fully taxable personally and may result in higher immediate tax costs.
2. Dividends
Dividends are paid from after-tax corporate profits and do not create RRSP contribution room. Depending on the source of corporate earnings, dividends may be classified as eligible or non-eligible, each receiving different tax treatment at the personal level. For many business owners, dividends provide a flexible way to withdraw funds while managing personal taxable income.
3. Capital dividends
As described above, capital dividends can be paid tax-free to shareholders when sufficient CDA balances exist. This can create significant planning opportunities, particularly after the sale of investments or the receipt of life insurance proceeds.
4. Shareholder loans
In some situations, shareholder loan arrangements can provide access to corporate funds. However, these strategies are governed by complex rules under the Income Tax Act and must be carefully reviewed before use. Improper use of shareholder loans can result in unintended tax consequences, including the full amount being included in the shareholder’s income.
Corporate investing and retirement planning
Many owners and professionals spend years building their businesses while accumulating significant wealth within their corporations. As retirement approaches, the focus shifts from accumulation to distribution.
The challenge is not simply maximizing returns; it is coordinating withdrawals from corporate accounts, registered accounts (RRSP/RRIF, TFSA), government benefits (CPP, OAS), and personal investments in a tax-efficient manner.
For example, withdrawing excessive corporate funds in a single year may push income into higher tax brackets and create unnecessary tax costs, while leaving too much capital trapped within a corporation can create complications later in retirement or upon death.
A well-designed retirement strategy considers both the corporate and personal balance sheets together, rather than treating them as separate entities.
The importance of professional advice
Corporate investing can provide significant opportunities, but it also introduces considerable complexity. Tax rules surrounding passive income, refundable taxes, capital dividends, shareholder compensation, and corporate structures are highly technical and subject to ongoing legislative change.
Decisions that appear straightforward on the surface can carry meaningful long-term tax implications. Successful corporate planning typically involves coordinated advice from a financial advisor, accountant (ideally a CPA with corporate tax experience), and a legal professional.
Disclaimer:
Gabriel Zitoli is a Financial Advisor with CI Assante Wealth Management Ltd. The opinions expressed are those of the author and not necessarily those of CI Assante Wealth Management Ltd. Please visit www.tmfg.ca to discuss your circumstances prior to acting on the information above. CI Assante Wealth Management Ltd. is a Member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund and the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization.
.